Your ideas, working in Notebook AI
All four ideas in "Design Ideas 11.12.26", and the principle behind them, are now working in the app and can be used today. This document shows each one in the order you wrote them, with a few minutes of steps to try it yourself. Where something is a stand-in for a future business arrangement, such as a real payment system or real retail partners, it is marked as a rehearsal.
Getting in
The home page is at mynotebookai.app. Choose Get Started there to sign in, or go straight to the app. If you created a passkey at the earlier temporary address, you will need to create it again here.
You have two ways to explore:
- The demo notebook. A ready-made account that looks like a family has been using it for a few weeks: a holiday being planned, home repairs, a birthday party, a science fair project, a business idea. Use it to see what the app feels like when it is full. The sign-in details were sent to you separately.
- Your own account. On the sign-in page choose First time? Create an account. You can use an email and password, or a passkey: your fingerprint, face or device PIN, with no password to remember. You will need the invite code that was sent to you with the sign-in details. Your account starts empty and is entirely yours.
A quick tour of the screen:
- Left: your spaces (Family, Home, Travel, Work) and your conversations.
- Middle: the conversation you are in.
- Right: the memory board. It holds sticky notes of key ideas and the "living note" that summarises the conversation and updates itself as you talk.
- Top right: search, clips, your rebate balance, and your name, which opens your account.
1. Your knowledge belongs to you
"Your conversations. Your ideas. Your knowledge. Always yours."
The app keeps this promise in three ways: you can take everything with you at any time, cancelling does not lock you out, and you can leave completely.
What you asked for. The customer owns what they create. The subscription pays for the intelligence and the service, never for access to their own information.
What we built.
- You can take everything, at any time. One button downloads the whole notebook. What arrives is a folder of ordinary documents, one per conversation, each with its summary and the full conversation, organised by space. They open in Word, Google Docs, Notion or any notes app.
- Cancelling does not lock you out. If a subscriber cancels, the AI stops answering new questions and nothing else changes. Every conversation, note and clip is still there to read and search, and the download button still works. The app shows the date the notebook will be kept until, and resuming brings everything back exactly as it was.
- You can leave completely. A subscriber can permanently delete everything they own.
Try it
- Sign in to the demo notebook and click the name in the top right corner.
- Under Your knowledge is yours, click Download everything. Open the downloaded folder and open any file. It reads like a tidy document.
- Under Plan, click Cancel plan. Close the panel and look around: everything is still readable, the message box is switched off, and a banner offers the download. Click Resume and it is all back.
Rehearsal, not yet real. There is no payment system connected, so "plan" is a switch rather than a real subscription. The 90-day keeping period shown after cancelling is a placeholder for a policy you will want to choose.
2. Helpful Links
Live AI Conversation → Relevant Need Arises → Helpful Links Available → User Chooses Whether to View Them
The app follows exactly that flow, and each of your conditions is built into how it works.
What you asked for. Useful resources offered alongside a conversation without interrupting it. Based only on what is being discussed right now. Out of sight unless the person chooses to look. Paid links clearly marked. Temporary, unless the person decides to keep one. And advertising must never shape what the AI says.
What we built. As you talk, a Helpful Links button at the top of the conversation quietly keeps count. Nothing appears in the conversation itself. If you click the button, a panel slides out with resources related to what you were just discussing. Some are ordinary, such as a national parks guide or a government advice page. Some are from paid partners, and each of those is labelled Sponsored.
| Your condition | How the app holds to it |
|---|---|
| Only the current conversation | The part of the app that chooses links is only ever handed the message you just typed. It has no way to look at anything else in the notebook. |
| Unseen unless chosen | Links never appear in the conversation, only behind the button. |
| A running number on the button | It is there, and it changes colour when something new arrives. |
| Paid links identified | Every paid link carries a Sponsored label wherever it appears, including if you save it or download it. |
| Advertising never influences the answer | The AI writes its answer first and is never shown the list of partners. Links are chosen afterwards, separately. |
| Temporary | Links are never saved. Leave the conversation and they are gone. |
| Saving is your choice | Each link offers Save to living note and Save as clip. Nothing is kept unless you click one. |
Try it
- In your own account, start a new chat and ask something practical, such as: "Help me plan a week-long family camping trip to the national parks, with a couple of hotel nights."
- Read the answer. It contains no advertising, and the Helpful Links number has gone up.
- Click Helpful Links. Save one to the living note. It appears on the right under Saved resources.
- Click on a different conversation, then come back. The links have gone. The one you saved is still there.
Rehearsal, not yet real. The paid partners are invented names for demonstration, and the set of links is a small sample we wrote ourselves. The real version would draw on actual partner offers.
3. Notebook AI Rebates
"When Notebook AI benefits financially from helping you find something useful, we believe you should benefit too."
The whole journey works, from clicking a link to money in the subscriber's balance.
What you asked for. When someone follows a Helpful Link and buys something, and Notebook AI earns a referral fee, share part of it with the subscriber, so Helpful Links feel like a benefit rather than advertising.
What we built. Sponsored links show the rebate rate up front ("4% rebate"). When a purchase is reported, the subscriber's share appears in their Rebates balance at the top of the screen: first as pending, then available once the partner confirms the sale, then paid out. The split is currently set to half of whatever Notebook AI earns. It is a single setting and can be anything you choose.
One point matters especially for trust. To credit a rebate, the app records only who clicked, which partner, and when. It does not record what the person was talking about, so there is nothing from which an advertising profile could be built.
Try it
- In the demo notebook, click Rebates at the top. You will see a history: one rebate paid, one available, one pending.
- To see the whole journey yourself, open Helpful Links in any conversation and click Open on a sponsored link. A practice shop opens in a new tab.
- Enter an order amount and click Complete demo purchase. The page tells you how much you earned.
- Go back to the app. Your Rebates balance has gone up. Open it, click Confirm on the new entry, then Pay out.
Rehearsal, not yet real. Everything commercial here is simulated: the partners, the shop, the purchase and the payout. Making it real means agreements with referral networks or individual retailers, and a way to pay subscribers. Those are business arrangements rather than building work, and the app is ready to receive them.
4. Bring your existing AI with you
"The AI may change. Your Notebook AI knowledge stays with you."
Both halves work: you can change the AI at any time, and you can bring earlier conversations in from elsewhere.
What you asked for. Let people use the AI they already use, and bring their existing conversations with them, so Notebook AI is where their knowledge lives regardless of which AI is behind it.
Choose your AI, change it any time. Under the message box is a menu of AI models. Change it whenever you like, even in the middle of a conversation. The conversation, the living note and everything the notebook remembers carry on untouched. Each answer is labelled with the AI that wrote it.
Bring your history. Import from another AI, on the left, accepts:
- the download that ChatGPT or Claude will send any of their users on request, from which you choose the conversations to bring across;
- a conversation copied and pasted from anywhere else, such as Gemini, Copilot or Grok;
- a previous download from Notebook AI itself (conversations and their living notes come back; clips and saved links are not restored yet).
Once imported, a conversation behaves like any other. It can be searched, it can be drawn on in future chats, and one click on Build note has the AI read it and write its living note.
Try it
- Open any conversation in the demo notebook, change the model in the menu under the message box, and ask a follow-up question. Nothing is lost.
- In the demo notebook, find Kitchen remodel ideas. It is marked imported and came from ChatGPT.
- To import one yourself, click Import from another AI, choose Paste a conversation, and paste any exchange you have had with another assistant. Then click Build note.
What this does not do. It does not connect directly to someone's ChatGPT or Claude account and pull their history automatically. It works with the copy each service lets its own users download. Whether any of those companies would permit a direct connection is a question to put to them; we have not assumed they would.
The bigger principle
"The AI creates the conversation. Notebook AI helps the user turn that conversation into knowledge they can keep, organize, develop, retrieve, and use again."
Each of those five words is something you can see in the app.
| Your word | In the app |
|---|---|
| Keep | Download everything; clip the answers worth keeping; access that survives cancelling |
| Organize | Spaces for each part of life; every conversation named automatically |
| Develop | The living note and sticky notes grow as you talk; next steps can be ticked off |
| Retrieve | Search across everything you have ever discussed |
| Use again | New conversations draw on earlier ones; share a conversation with family or colleagues |
The demo notebook is the best place to feel this. Open Utah national parks trip — July and look at the right-hand side: the plan, the bookings already ticked off and the links worth keeping, all gathered from an ordinary conversation without anyone taking notes.
Which AI should power Notebook AI?
Our suggestion is to stay on Gemini 3.5 Flash-Lite for now. We have since tested fourteen models from other companies, and two are worth a closer look: Meta's Muse Ember as a cheaper everyday model, and Claude Haiku 5.5 as a more thorough one. Your fourth idea means the choice is never permanent, but it decides how good the answers feel, how long people wait, and what each conversation costs you.
Google's models
The app is currently connected to Google's Gemini family. We put three everyday questions to every Gemini model available to us, through the app itself, exactly as a subscriber would: planning a family trip, deciding the order of home repairs on a budget, and turning a business idea into a one-page outline.
Read the results with three cautions:
- This was three questions, not a full study.
- The waiting times were measured while several models ran at once, so treat them as a comparison between models rather than exact figures.
- The costs are estimates for a typical mid-conversation message. For the slower "thinking" models they are probably on the low side.
Every model that ran gave a sensible, correct answer and produced a proper living note every time. The differences were in depth, waiting time and cost.
| Model | Typical wait | Answers | Rough cost per 1,000 messages | In short |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gemini 3.5 Flash-Lite | 2–3 seconds | Clear and complete, a few short paragraphs | about $2 | Our pick for everyday use. Fast enough to feel like conversation, inexpensive, and Google supports it until at least July 2027. |
| Gemini 3.1 Flash-Lite | 2–3 seconds | Correct but brief, about half the length | about $1.30 | The cheapest. Fine for quick questions; feels thin on planning questions. |
| Gemini 3 Flash (preview) | about 8 seconds | Fuller than the Lite models | about $2.60 | Good value, but a "preview": Google can change or withdraw it. |
| Gemini 3.8 Flash | 15–45 seconds | Long and well organised | about $4 now, about $8 from January | Google's current main mid-range model. Noticeably slow for chat, and its price doubles on 1 January. |
| Gemini 3.5 Flash | about 12 seconds | Long and detailed | about $10 | Good answers, but costs more than the newer 3.8 for similar results. |
| Gemini 3.1 Pro (preview) | 20–30 seconds | Long, careful | about $12 | A heavyweight meant for hard reasoning. More than a notebook conversation needs. |
| Gemini 4 Hydrogen | 8–70 seconds | Among the most detailed | about $10 | Four days old when tested. Very thorough; waiting times varied widely. |
| Gemini 4 Argon | 30–45 seconds | The most detailed | about $15 now, about $30 from December | Google's new top tier. Excellent answers, but too slow and too costly for everyday chat. |
| Gemini 4 Carbon | not tested | not tested | not tested | Google's most capable model. We could not test it: our account's capacity for it was exhausted. |
Three models we set aside: Gemini 3.6 Flash and 3.7 Flash work today but Google is retiring them (19 November and 28 January), and the older Gemini 2.5 models have already been switched off.
What this suggests
- For everyday conversation, a small fast model is the right choice. People talk to a notebook the way they talk to a person. A two-second reply keeps that feeling and a thirty-second one breaks it. The small models were also accurate on everything we asked.
- The bigger models earn their place on occasional, heavier jobs. Examples are writing the living note for a long imported history, or a careful plan. A sensible design is a fast model for conversation and a stronger one for those moments, which the app can already do because the model can be chosen per request.
- Offer a short, considered list rather than everything. Subscribers do not need eleven versions of one company's AI. Three or four clearly named choices, such as "Fast", "Thorough" and one or two from other companies, would make your fourth idea tangible without confusing anyone.
Other companies' AI, tested
We then tested fourteen models from other companies through the app. Each first answered the same 39 questions, ranging from a simple greeting to a long planning request. The three that did best, plus the current Gemini model, then answered 312 questions each.
These tests measured what can be counted: whether every reply arrived in a usable form, whether the living note was complete, how long people waited, and what each message cost. They did not judge which model gives the better answer. That needs a person to read the answers side by side, and that review has not been done yet.
| Model | From | Usable replies | Living note complete | Typical wait | Cost per 1,000 messages | In short |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gemini 3.5 Flash-Lite (current) | 312 of 312 | Almost always | about 2 seconds | about $1.10 | The fastest and most consistent. Its only drawback is cost. | |
| Muse Ember | Meta | 312 of 312 | Usually; it left out next steps on about 1 reply in 10 | about 2 seconds | about $0.50 | Nearly as fast as Gemini at half the cost. It was released on 9 November, so it has very little track record. |
| Claude Haiku 5.5 | Anthropic | 310 of 312 | Almost always | about 5 seconds, up to 13 | about $0.50 | Complete notes at half the cost, but too slow to be the everyday model. |
| GPT-6 Luna | OpenAI | 312 of 312 | About half the time | about 4 seconds, up to 12 | about $0.25 | The cheapest, but it often left the living note without ideas or next steps. |
Read these results with three cautions:
- All the questions were asked within one half hour, so the results say nothing about other times of day.
- Gemini is connected directly, while the others were reached through an intermediary service, which adds a little waiting time.
- The costs are for short conversations. Long conversations cost more, which is why Gemini 3.5 Flash-Lite shows about $2 in the earlier table and about $1.10 here.
The other ten models were set aside:
- Too slow for conversation: Grok 4.3 (about 15 seconds), DeepSeek V4.1 Flash, Nvidia Nemotron 3.5 Lightning and Mistral Large 4 (about 50 seconds).
- Unreliable: gpt-oss and MiniMax M3 each returned a number of unusable replies.
- No advantage over the four above: GLM 5.3 Flash, Mistral Small, Cohere Command A+ and GPT-6.1 Terra.
We also tested whether a model could be talked out of its instructions by a message telling it to ignore them. gpt-oss and GPT-6.1 Terra complied. None of the four models in the table did, in eight attempts each.
Not yet tested: the stronger models that could serve as a "Thorough" option, such as Claude Sonnet 5.5 and GPT-6.1 Sol. They cost roughly ten times as much per message.
A point about privacy
Whichever AI you choose, what it does with your subscribers' conversations matters as much as how clever it is. Google, Anthropic, OpenAI and xAI all state that conversations sent by a business like yours are not used to train their models unless you agree. That should be a condition for any AI added to the list, and it is a promise worth making to subscribers in plain words. Our tests were restricted to providers that do not keep conversations or train on them.
One to avoid: DeepSeek's own service. Its published policy says conversations may be used to train its models and are stored in China, which sits badly with "your knowledge is always yours".
Our suggestion
Stay on Gemini 3.5 Flash-Lite for now; it is what the live app uses, and nothing we tested was both faster and more consistent. The next step is for a person to read the answers from the four models side by side, without knowing which model wrote which. If Muse Ember's answers hold up, it could halve the cost of everyday conversation, and Claude Haiku 5.5 is a candidate for the "Thorough" option. The app's built-in comparison screen (the flask icon at the top) shows the Gemini models side by side today.
What comes next
Each item below replaces a stand-in with the real thing. None of them changes what you have seen.
| To make real | What it needs |
|---|---|
| Subscriptions | Choosing a payment provider and your pricing |
| Sponsored links and rebates | Agreements with referral networks or retailers, and a way to pay subscribers |
| What happens after cancelling | Your decision on how long a notebook is kept |
| Direct connections to other AI services | A conversation with each provider about what they allow |
| Which AI powers the app | A decision from the comparison above, ideally after trying two or three with real users |
We suggest starting with the demo notebook for a day or two, then creating your own account and having a few real conversations. The questions that come out of that will be the most useful guide to what to build next.